Socrates once noticed that his eldest son, Lamprocles, was fed up with his mother. Lamprocles didn't dispute how much she had done for him, but he insisted that "no one could put up with her vile temper." Her words, he complained, were things "one wouldn't listen to for anything in the world" (Xenophon, Memorabilia 2.2.7-8, E. C. Marchant's translation).

Socrates asked him to look at what she did rather than what she said. "She nurses you devotedly in sickness and sees that you want for nothing," he pointed out, and "she prays the gods to bless you abundantly" (2.2.10).

Plenty of families are like that. The words "I appreciate you" rarely come up, but the care shows up in other ways, if you know where to look.

These gestures can suggest affection and appreciation when they form part of a wider pattern of respect. They don't tell you everything about a relationship, and they don't make hurtful treatment acceptable. With that in mind, here are eight of them.

1. You're one of the first people they tell when something goes right

We usually think of family support in terms of hard times. But who someone calls with good news can say just as much.

In a set of four studies, people who shared their good news with others felt better day to day, beyond the boost from the good event itself. When the person they told responded with real enthusiasm, the benefit was larger. And close relationships in which a partner usually responded that way were linked to more intimacy and satisfaction (Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2004).

Those studies focused on the person sharing the news, not the person hearing it. But if your sister texts you the moment she gets the job, or your dad calls to tell you the tomatoes finally came up, it's fair to take it as a small compliment. They wanted to share it with you. Reply with a question, such as "How did you find out?", so they get to enjoy it a second time.

2. They remember what you'd want

Mencius told a story about the philosopher Zengzi and the way he cared for his elderly father. Zengzi always made sure there was wine and meat at his father's meals. When the dishes were being cleared, "he would ask respectfully to whom he should give what was left" (Mencius 4A.19, James Legge's translation).

Zengzi's own son later fed him just as well, but never asked that question. Mencius called the son's approach "nourishing the mouth and body," and Zengzi's "nourishing the will": attending to what his father wished for, not only what he needed.

Families do this all the time without comment. Your brother remembers you don't like onions. Your mother keeps the brand of tea you drink, even though no one else in the house does. Those small acts of remembering are a kind of attention, and attention is a form of appreciation.

3. They show it with practical help

For many people, especially in older generations, love is something you do rather than something you say. A parent who would never write "I'm proud of you" in a card will still check your tires, drop off a meal when you're sick or drive two hours to help you move.

It can be easy to overlook, because it often arrives without any explanation attached. The next time someone in your family fixes, carries or cooks something for you, try reading it as the message it probably is.

A simple "Thanks, that made my week easier" tells them the message got through.

4. They check on your well-being

Back to Lamprocles. When he complained about his mother's sharp words, Socrates reminded him: "You know well that there is no malice in what your mother says to you; on the contrary, she wishes you to be blessed above all other beings" (Memorabilia 2.2.9).

"Are you eating properly?" "Is that car safe?" "You work too hard." These can land as nagging, especially if you're an adult who's been managing fine for years. But for many relatives, worry is how care comes out.

Concern is easier to recognize when they also listen to your answer. You might say, "I know you're worried. I'm managing it, and I'll ask if I need help." How they respond matters too.

5. They brag about you when you're not in the room

Plutarch noticed something interesting about praise in families. An uncle, he thought, should praise his nephews "without stint," because "it is, perhaps, offensive to praise one's own son, yet to praise a brother's is a noble thing" (On Brotherly Love 21, W. C. Helmbold's translation).

Plutarch was discussing an uncle's affection for his nephews. Families can also express pride indirectly: a cousin mentions that your aunt has been telling everyone about your qualification, or a neighbor repeats something appreciative your father said about your work.

If you've ever heard from an aunt that your father "never stops talking about" your work, that's this sign in action. It counts, even if it reached you secondhand.

6. They take your suggestions seriously

Plutarch hoped younger brothers would follow their older brothers out of "imitation, not rivalry," because "imitation is the act of one who admires, but rivalry of one who envies" (On Brotherly Love 16).

Your mother tries the recipe you recommended. Your brother uses the approach you suggested for a difficult conversation and later tells you it helped. Taking your advice seriously can show that they value your judgment.

7. They take your side quietly

Plutarch had advice for a son whose father was angry with his brother. Instead of looking good by comparison, the right way was "to take his share of it and bear the brunt of it together with his brother, by such assistance making the anger lighter" (On Brotherly Love 9).

In families, this rarely gets announced. It's the sibling who changes the subject when your career comes up at dinner, or the parent who tells a critical relative, "They're doing their best." Sometimes you only find out about it years later.

When you do notice it, it's worth a quiet word afterwards: "Thanks for backing me up in there."

8. They wait for you

Plutarch described the kind of brother who includes his sibling in everything worthwhile, one who "employs him when present, waits for him when absent" (On Brotherly Love 13).

Families show this in small ways. They hold off on cutting the cake until you arrive. They ask, "Is she coming?" before setting the date for a reunion. They save a decision about the family home until everyone, including you, has had a say.

Being waited for is easy to take for granted. It means that, to them, the gathering isn't quite complete without you.

Silence isn't always appreciation

None of this means you should explain away every cold or hurtful thing a relative says. Some criticism is just criticism. If a family member regularly belittles you, the occasional practical favor doesn't cancel that out, and it's reasonable to want more.

It also works the other way. If your family doesn't show many of these signs, it doesn't prove you aren't valued. Some families are reserved, some are going through their own struggles and some simply never learned how. And wanting to hear the words out loud now and then is not asking too much.

One place to start

Plutarch didn't keep his own feelings to himself. In the middle of his essay, he wrote that of all the good things fortune had given him, "my brother Timon's affection for me has always transcended and still transcends all the rest" (On Brotherly Love 16).

If you'd like to hear more appreciation in your family, try saying it first. Pick one relative this week and name one specific thing they do, such as "I always notice you save me a seat." It's a small sentence, and it may make it easier for them to say something back.